MPJ Feature Story

Picture Takers vs Picture Makers?
by Ken Hackman


   "I never set up a picture, I'm a photojournalist, I shoot life as it happens". "Posing and direction in photography destroys the reality of the event and is dishonest or unethical!" "I take pictures, I don't make pictures!"  We have all heard or stated ale above at one time or an-other.
   Photojournalism is usually considered by its practitioners to be the capturing of the decisive moment, the essence of the event, the candid occurrence without any interference direction or posing from the photojournalist. In other words picture taking.
   Picture "making" was relegated to the still life, portrait' commercial, advertising, industrial, etc. photographers. Is photojournalism strictly picture taking or is there a place for picture making? I feel a better question is, did the photograph communicate the intended purpose?
   Too often we attempt to excuse our bad photography by stating that we had no control of the situation, we were being unobtrusive, not interfering with the reality of the event of course we also failed to communicate but we excuse ourselves with the fact that we didn't direct or suggest or pose anything.
   Somehow I don't think the customer is going to be interested in your journalistic integrity, etc. They wanted a picture and you failed to deliver.
   As visual communicators our obligation is to provide to our customers, photographs which satisfy their requirements. If it is a news events, we go and "take" pictures, if it is a feature or other requirement we may have to "make" the picture.
   Considering that much of what we do as military photojournalists falls into the feature, annual report- style photography it is important that we all know how to "make" pictures.
   As professional communicators we must be able to accept an often-ambiguous request from a customer and develop a concept, which will illustrate that request. Then using our professional expertise produce a story telling photograph. The key is to be able to analyze and ascertain the best way (at least in your mind) of telling the story. Then using your skills  you go out and literally "make" the picture.
   A side benefit to "making" pictures is that when you are covering an uncontrolled event you will find that you will "make" better photos even through you are "taking" them.
   "Make", "Take", it really doesn't matter. As professionals we should be able to "make or take" depending on the situation of the moment. Mastery of both is essential to today's working photojournalists.
-KLH-

Next Story in the Archive

Home Page
Visit the
MPJ Forum
View Images
New Gallery
Old Gallery
Past Stories
Story Archive
Our Links
Web Links
Photo Magazines
Becoming a Military MPJ
SEI Guidelines
MPJ Connection
Submission
Guidelines

Please Sign the
Guest Book
Roll Call
1964-1973
1974-1982
1983-1993
1994-Current

Links of Note
The below link features work by Marine Corps  assigned to Camp Pendleton, Calif. Much of the work is from recent assignments in Iraq.
They'd all like your comments…

The Scout Gallery

Updated and
New eMail Listings
Photojournalists
Will no longer be listed here on this site. Due to the possibility of spammers harvesting your address I've decided to stop listing them. If you need someone's email address drop me a line and I'll let you know if I have it. Also, you might check the MPJ Connection forum and see if they've listed their email link there as that's their choice. - Jim

Combat Camera
Glenn King
Home

David Underwood Home

Kim Haggerty
Home

PJ Web Sites
Mark Borosch
Class of 1991
Alan Wycheck
Class of 1988
Derrick Goode
Class of 2000
Chad McNeeley
Class of 2002
Bob Fehringer
Class of 1977
Bill Henderson
Class of 1981
Russ Pollanen
Class of 1988
Ken Wright
Class of 1995

Site Last Updated
March 9, 2006